Backup of Hattie’s Ranking list of 256 Influences And Effect Sizes Related To Student Achievement

hattie-ranking-256-effects-updated-august-2017

Source: www.visiblelearningplus.com/content/250-influences-student-achievement (Retrieved 1 November 2017 / PDF)

RANK	INFLUENCE	EFFECT SIZE COHEN'S d	DOMAIN	SUBDOMAIN
1	Teacher estimates of achievement	1.62	Teacher	Teacher attributes
2	Collective teacher efficacy	1.57	School	Leadership
3	Self-reported grades	1.33	Student	Prior knowledge and background
4	Cognitive task analysis	1.29	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Learning Intentions
5	Response to intervention	1.29	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Feedback
6	Piagetian programs	1.28	Student	Prior knowledge and background
7	Jigsaw method	1.2	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
8	Conceptual change programs	0.99	Curricula	Other curricula programs
9	Prior ability	0.94	Student	Prior knowledge and background
10	Strategy to integrate with prior knowledge	0.93	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
11	Self-efficacy	0.92	Student	Beliefs, Attitudes and Dispositions
12	Teacher credibility	0.9	Teacher	Teacher attributes
13	Micro teaching	0.88	Teacher	Teacher education
14	Transfer Strategies	0.86	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Strategies emphasizing student meta-cognitive/self-regulated learning
15	Seeking help from peers	0.83	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Strategies emphasizing student meta-cognitive/self-regulated learning
16	Classroom discussion	0.82	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Feedback
17	Scaffolding	0.82	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
18	Deliberate practice	0.79	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
19	Summarization	0.79	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
20	Effort	0.77	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
21	Interventions for learning disabled students	0.77	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations that emphasize school-wide teaching strategies
22	Mnemonics	0.76	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
23	Planning and prediction	0.76	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Learning Intentions
24	Repeated Reading programs	0.75	Curricula	Reading, Writing, and the Arts
25	Teacher clarity	0.75	Teacher	Teacher attributes
26	Elaboration and Organisation	0.75	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Strategies emphasizing student meta-cognitive/self-regulated learning
27	Evaluation and reflection	0.75	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Strategies emphasizing student meta-cognitive/self-regulated learning
28	Reciprocal teaching	0.74	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
29	Rehearsal and memorization	0.73	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
30	Comprehensive instructional	0.72	Curricula	Reading, Writing, and the Arts
31	Phonics instruction	0.7	Curricula	Reading, Writing, and the Arts
32	Feedback	0.7	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Feedback
33	Deep motivation and approach	0.69	Student	Motivational approach, orientation
34	Field independence	0.68	Student	Prior knowledge and background
35	Acceleration	0.68	Classroom	School curricula for gifted students
36	Goals	0.68	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Learning Intentions
37	Problem solving teaching	0.68	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
38	Outlining and transforming	0.66	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
39	Concept mapping	0.64	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Learning Intentions
40	Vocabulary programs	0.62	Curricula	Reading, Writing, and the Arts
41	Creativity programs	0.62	Curricula	Other curricula programs
42	Classroom behavioral	0.62	Classroom	Classroom influences
43	Setting standards for self judgement	0.62	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Learning Intentions
44	Teachers not labeling students	0.61	Teacher	Teacher student interactions
45	Prior - high school to university	0.6	Student	Prior knowledge and background
46	Meta-cognitive strategies	0.6	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Strategies emphasizing student meta-cognitive/self-regulated learning
47	Help seeking	0.6	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
48	Spaced vs, Mass Practice	0.6	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
49	Direct Instruction	0.6	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
50	Mathematics	0.59	Curricula	Math and Sciences
51	Goal difficulty	0.59	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Learning Intentions
52	Spelling programs	0.58	Curricula	Reading, Writing, and the Arts
53	Tactile stimulation programs	0.58	Curricula	Play Programs
54	Strategy monitoring	0.58	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Strategies emphasizing student meta-cognitive/self-regulated learning
55	Service learning	0.58	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using out of school learning
56	Working memory	0.57	Student	Prior knowledge and background
57	Pre-term birth weight	0.57	Student	Physical Influences
58	Mastery learning	0.57	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Success Criteria
59	Teaching strategies	0.57	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
60	Technology with learning needs students	0.57	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
61	Concentration/Persistence/Engagement	0.56	Student	Beliefs, Attitudes and Dispositions
62	Pre school with at risk students	0.56	School	Pre-school experiences
63	Prior achievement	0.55	Student	Prior knowledge and background
64	Visual-Perception programs	0.55	Curricula	Reading, Writing, and the Arts
65	Self-verbalization and Self-questioning	0.55	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Strategies emphasizing student meta-cognitive/self-regulated learning
66	Cooperative vs. individualistic learning	0.55	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
67	Technology in other subjects	0.55	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
68	Practice testing	0.54	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
69	Interactive video methods	0.54	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
70	Second/Third chance programs	0.53	Curricula	Reading, Writing, and the Arts
71	Enrichment	0.53	Classroom	School curricula for gifted students
72	Peer influences	0.53	Classroom	Classroom influences
73	Peer tutoring	0.53	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Strategies emphasizing student perspectives in learning
74	Cooperative vs. competitive learning	0.53	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
75	Home environment	0.52	Home	Family dynamics
76	Socioeconomic status	0.52	Home	Family resources
77	Teacher-Student relationships	0.52	Teacher	Teacher student interactions
78	Self-regulation strategies	0.52	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Strategies emphasizing student meta-cognitive/self-regulated learning
79	Record keeping	0.52	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
80	Parental Involvement	0.5	Home	Family dynamics
81	Student rating of quality of teaching	0.5	Teacher	Teacher student interactions
82	Note taking	0.5	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
83	Underlining and Highlighting	0.5	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
84	Time on Task	0.49	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
85	Science	0.48	Curricula	Math and Sciences
86	School effects	0.48	School	Other school effects
87	Goal intentions	0.48	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Learning Intentions
88	Providing formative evaluation	0.48	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Feedback
89	Questioning	0.48	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Feedback
90	Intelligent tutoring systems	0.48	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
91	Comprehension programs	0.47	Curricula	Reading, Writing, and the Arts
92	Integrated Curricula programs	0.47	Curricula	Other curricula programs
93	Small group learning	0.47	Classroom	Classroom composition effects
94	Computer assisted instruction	0.47	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
95	Task value	0.46	Student	Beliefs, Attitudes and Dispositions
96	Study skills	0.46	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
97	Relative age within a class	0.45	Student	Physical Influences
98	Writing programs	0.45	Curricula	Reading, Writing, and the Arts
99	Imagery	0.45	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
100	Achieving motivation and approach	0.44	Student	Motivational approach, orientation
101	Early Intervention	0.44	School	Pre-school experiences
102	Classroom cohesion	0.44	Classroom	Classroom influences
103	Inductive teaching	0.44	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
104	Technology with elementary students	0.44	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
105	Exposure to reading	0.43	Curricula	Reading, Writing, and the Arts
106	Outdoor/ Adventure programs	0.43	Curricula	Other curricula programs
107	School size	0.43	School	School compositional effects
108	Teacher expectations	0.43	Teacher	Teacher attributes
109	Philosophy in schools	0.43	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
110	Teaching communication skills and strategies	0.43	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
111	Motivation	0.42	Student	Motivational approach, orientation
112	Reducing anxiety	0.42	Student	Motivational approach, orientation
113	Elaborative-Interrogation	0.42	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Strategies emphasizing student meta-cognitive/self-regulated learning
114	Behavioral organizers/Adjunct questions	0.42	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Learning Intentions
115	Technology in writing	0.42	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
116	Technology with college students	0.42	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
117	Self-concept	0.41	Student	Beliefs, Attitudes and Dispositions
118	Professional development	0.41	Teacher	Teacher education
119	Creativity and achievement	0.4	Student	Prior knowledge and background
120	Goal commitment	0.4	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Learning Intentions
121	Cooperative learning	0.4	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
122	Inquiry based teaching	0.4	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
123	After school programs	0.4	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using out of school learning
124	Social skills programs	0.39	Curricula	Play Programs
125	Prior - to adult performance	0.38	Student	Prior knowledge and background
126	Drama/Arts programs	0.38	Curricula	Reading, Writing, and the Arts
127	Career Interventions	0.38	Curricula	Other curricula programs
128	Music based programs	0.37	Curricula	Reading, Writing, and the Arts
129	Worked examples	0.37	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Success Criteria
130	Mobile phones	0.37	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
131	Bilingual programs	0.36	Curricula	Other curricula programs
132	Student centered teaching	0.36	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Student focused interventions
133	Attitude to content domains	0.35	Student	Beliefs, Attitudes and Dispositions
134	Counseling effects	0.35	School	Other school effects
135	Classroom management	0.35	Classroom	Classroom influences
136	Gaming/ simulations	0.35	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
137	Chess	0.34	Curricula	Other curricula programs
138	Motivation/ character programs	0.34	Curricula	Other curricula programs
139	Decreasing disruptive behavior	0.34	Classroom	Classroom influences
140	Collaborative learning	0.34	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
141	Teaching creative thinking	0.34	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations that emphasize school-wide teaching strategies
142	Stereotype threat	0.33	Student	Beliefs, Attitudes and Dispositions
143	Head start programs	0.33	School	Pre-school experiences
144	Technology in mathematics	0.33	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
145	Drugs	0.32	Student	Physical Influences
146	Principals/ School leaders	0.32	School	Leadership
147	School climate	0.32	School	Leadership
148	Teacher effects	0.32	Teacher	Teacher attributes
149	Adjunct aids	0.32	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
150	External accountability systems	0.31	School	School resourcing
151	Matching style of learning	0.31	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Student focused interventions
152	Manipulative materials on math	0.3	Curricula	Math and Sciences
153	Ability grouping for gifted students	0.3	Classroom	School curricula for gifted students
154	Teaching test taking and coaching	0.3	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
155	Technology with high school students	0.3	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
156	Mindfulness	0.29	Student	Beliefs, Attitudes and Dispositions
157	Different types of early intervention	0.29	School	Pre-school experiences
158	Home visiting	0.29	Home	Family dynamics
159	Cognitive behavioural programs	0.29	Classroom	Classroom influences
160	Online, digital tools	0.29	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
161	Technology in Reading/Literacy	0.29	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
162	Homework	0.29	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using out of school learning
163	Desegregation	0.28	School	School compositional effects
164	Comprehensive Teaching Reforms	0.28	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations that emphasize school-wide teaching strategies
165	Use of calculators	0.27	Curricula	Math and Sciences
166	Early Intervention in the home	0.27	School	Pre-school experiences
167	Mainstreaming	0.27	Classroom	Classroom composition effects
168	Personality	0.26	Student	Beliefs, Attitudes and Dispositions
169	Exercise/Relaxation	0.26	Student	Physical Influences
170	Illness (lack of)	0.26	Student	Physical Influences
171	Pre school programs	0.26	School	Pre-school experiences
172	Out of school curricula experiences	0.26	School	School compositional effects
173	Volunteer tutors	0.26	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Strategies emphasizing student perspectives in learning
174	Problem based learning	0.26	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
175	Use of PowerPoint	0.26	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
176	Grit/ Incremental vs, entity thinking	0.25	Student	Beliefs, Attitudes and Dispositions
177	Adopted children	0.25	Home	Family structure
178	Religious Schools	0.24	School	Types of school
179	Competitive vs. individualistic learning	0.24	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
180	Summer school	0.23	School	Types of school
181	Divorced or remarriage	0.23	Home	Family structure
182	Teacher personality	0.23	Teacher	Teacher attributes
183	Individualized instruction	0.23	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Student focused interventions
184	Programmed instruction	0.23	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
185	Technology in science	0.23	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
186	Teacher verbal ability	0.22	Teacher	Teacher attributes
187	Clickers	0.22	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
188	Visual/Audio-visual methods	0.22	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
189	Finances	0.21	School	School resourcing
190	Class size	0.21	Classroom	Classroom composition effects
191	Interleaved practice	0.21	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Learning strategies
192	Discovery based teaching	0.21	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
193	Technology in small groups	0.21	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
194	Special College programs	0.21	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations that emphasize school-wide teaching strategies
195	Extra-curricula programs	0.2	Curricula	Other curricula programs
196	Fathers	0.2	Home	Family structure
197	Aptitude/treatment interactions	0.19	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Student focused interventions
198	Learning hierarchies	0.19	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Learning Intentions
199	Co-/ Team teaching	0.19	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations that emphasize school-wide teaching strategies
200	Within class grouping	0.18	Classroom	Classroom composition effects
201	Web based learning	0.18	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
202	Lack of stress	0.17	Student	Motivational approach, orientation
203	Other family structure	0.16	Home	Family structure
204	One on one laptops	0.16	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
205	Home-school programs	0.16	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using out of school learning
206	Sentence Combining programs	0.15	Curricula	Reading, Writing, and the Arts
207	Parental autonomy support	0.15	Home	Family dynamics
208	Distance Education	0.13	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using out of school learning
209	Morning vs, eveningness	0.12	Student	Beliefs, Attitudes and Dispositions
210	Ethnicity	0.12	Student	Physical Influences
211	Juvenile delinquent programs	0.12	Curricula	Other curricula programs
212	School choice	0.12	School	School compositional effects
213	Ability grouping	0.12	Classroom	Classroom composition effects
214	Mentoring	0.12	Classroom	Classroom influences
215	Teacher education	0.12	Teacher	Teacher education
216	Types of testing	0.12	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Strategies emphasizing Feedback
217	Teacher subject matter knowledge	0.11	Teacher	Teacher education
218	Diversity of students	0.1	School	School compositional effects
219	Background music	0.1	Classroom	Classroom influences
220	Diversity courses	0.09	Curricula	Other curricula programs
221	School calendars/timetables	0.09	School	Other school effects
222	Charter Schools	0.09	School	Types of school
223	Detracking	0.09	Classroom	Classroom composition effects
224	Gender on achievement	0.08	Student	Physical Influences
225	Perceptual-Motor programs	0.08	Curricula	Other curricula programs
226	Single sex schools	0.08	School	Types of school
227	Middle schools interventions	0.08	School	School compositional effects
228	Mastery goals	0.06	Student	Motivational approach, orientation
229	Whole language	0.06	Curricula	Reading, Writing, and the Arts
230	College halls of residence	0.05	School	School compositional effects
231	Teacher performance pay	0.05	Teacher	Teacher attributes
232	Breastfeeding	0.04	Student	Physical Influences
233	Multi-grade/age classes	0.04	Classroom	Classroom composition effects
234	Humour	0.04	Teaching - Focus on teaching/instructional strategies	Teaching/Instructional strategies
235	Parental employment	0.03	Home	Family resources
236	Student control over learning	0.02	Teaching - Focus on student learning strategies	Student focused interventions
237	Immigrant status	0.01	Home	Family resources
238	Open vs. Traditional	0.01	Classroom	Classroom composition effects
239	Technology in distance education	0.01	Teaching: Focus on implementation method	Implementations using technologies
240	Performance goals	-0.01	Student	Motivational approach, orientation
241	Summer vacation effect	-0.02	School	Types of school
242	Sleep	-0.05	Student	Physical Influences
243	Surface motivation and approach	-0.11	Student	Motivational approach, orientation
244	Welfare Policies	-0.12	Home	Family resources
245	Military deployment	-0.16	School	School compositional effects
246	Television	-0.18	Home	Family dynamics
247	Not being liked in class	-0.19	Classroom	Classroom influences
248	Suspension/ Expelling students	-0.2	School	Other school effects
249	Non-standard dialect use	-0.29	Student	Prior knowledge and background
250	Retention	-0.32	Classroom	Classroom composition effects
251	Corporal punishment in the home	-0.33	Home	Family dynamics
252	Mobility	-0.34	School	School compositional effects
253	Depression	-0.36	Student	Motivational approach, orientation
254	Boredom	-0.49	Student	Motivational approach, orientation
255	Deafness	-0.61	Student	Physical Influences
256	ADHD	-0.9	Student	Physical Influences

Backup: Our first visualization of the Hattie ranking (2009)
- visible-learning.org/2016/04/hattie-ranking-backup-of-138-effects/
- visible-learning.org/hattie-ranking-backup-195-effects/
- visible-learning.org/nvd3/visualize/hattie-ranking-interactive-2009-2011-2015.html